By Figran Team. We are associated with Figran, a commercial AI-assisted visual creation service. This original worksheet was prepared with AI assistance and checked for internal consistency. Its numbers are assigned for a classroom exercise, not measured research data or evidence of product performance. No software account is needed to complete it.
A copied number can look faithful while describing a different quantity. A label reading “18 cm” preserves the digits in “18 mm” but changes the stated length. A label reading only “18” preserves the digits while leaving a reader to guess the unit. A longer decimal can make a copied value look more exact without adding any source evidence.
This exercise follows the whole value-and-unit pair. It separates copying, conversion, display formatting, and claims about measurement. Use the invented source below as the complete evidence. Do not repair missing information by guessing what a real experiment might have done.
The invented source card
Card: Paper rectangle labels, revision 1.
The figure has one rectangle with two named dimensions. The source assigns width 18 mm and height 5 mm for this exercise. Every dimension label must identify both its quantity and its unit. There are no measurements, instrument specifications, uncertainty intervals, tolerances, or claims about manufacturing behind these assignments. The card does not establish how a measured value would be rounded.
For the conversion tasks, use the definitions 1 cm = 10 mm and 1 m = 1000 mm. These definitions are sufficient for the arithmetic here. Converting the unit does not provide a new measurement or establish a different uncertainty.
| Quantity | Assigned value | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Rectangle width | 18 | mm |
| Rectangle height | 5 | mm |
The two rows describe different quantities. Copying a valid value-and-unit pair from the height row into a width label is still a source error.
Six proposed labels to review
For each proposal, record what it claims, what source statement supports or conflicts with it, and your repair. Use these statuses: preserves the assignment, changes the assignment, missing unit, adds an unsupported measurement claim, or wrong quantity. Some proposals have more than one problem; explain both rather than forcing a single score.
- The width label is “Width: 18”. No surrounding legend defines a shared unit.
- The width label is “Width: 18 cm”. The reviewer says the digits match, so no further check is needed.
- The width label is “Width: 0.018 m”. A note says this is the source assignment expressed in metres.
- The width label is “Width: 18.000 mm”. Its caption says the three decimal places prove that a precise instrument measured the rectangle.
- The height label is “Height: 0.5 cm”. A note says the assigned height was converted from millimetres.
- The width label is “Width: 5 mm”. The reviewer found that exact pair in the source table and copied it.
Try all six before reading the repairs. Write a reason for each decision. “Looks right” does not identify the row, conversion, or missing source fact that a second reviewer needs to check.
Repairs and the evidence behind them
Case 1: missing unit. The card requires quantity and unit in every dimension label. With no shared-unit convention, “Width: 18” is incomplete. Repair it to “Width: 18 mm”. Do not infer centimetres from the size of the drawing or metres from the topic of a lesson.
Case 2: changes the assignment. The proposed 18 cm equals 180 mm under the supplied definition. The source assigns width 18 mm. Preserving digits while replacing a unit has multiplied the stated length by ten. Either restore “Width: 18 mm” or correctly convert it to “Width: 1.8 cm”. The repair changes a label; it does not claim that the physical rectangle has been measured again.
Case 3: preserves the assignment through conversion. Divide 18 by 1000 to express the assigned millimetres in metres: 18 mm = 0.018 m. Keep the quantity name and unit together. The leading zeros are part of the converted notation. The conversion does not establish an instrument, uncertainty, or an experimentally verified length.
Case 4: formatting plus an unsupported measurement claim. As a numerical assignment, 18.000 mm has the same magnitude as 18 mm. Extra trailing zeros can be a display format; they are not new evidence that an instrument was used. The caption contradicts the card's statement that there are no measurements behind the assignments. Restore the source's “Width: 18 mm” for this exercise and remove the instrument claim. In real measured material, decide reporting precision from the actual measurement and reporting rules; this invented card cannot supply them.
Case 5: preserves the assignment through conversion. The supplied definition gives 5 mm = 0.5 cm. The label still names height, and its note explains the changed unit. Keep it if centimetres are the chosen display convention. If a teaching visual mixes units, make each unit visible; a learner should not have to infer whether a number belongs to the width or height row.
Case 6: wrong quantity. The value-and-unit pair 5 mm is supported for height, not width. A source match must include the quantity identity. Repair the width label to 18 mm, and retain 5 mm only for the height label. A correct unit does not resolve an incorrect row mapping.
A repair log another reader can check
Make one line for each edited label:
Quantity and source row | Original assigned value and unit | Proposed label | Conversion factor, if used | New label | Added claim removed or left unresolved.
Example: Width row | 18 mm | Width: 18 cm | 1 cm = 10 mm | Width: 1.8 cm | Removed “matching digits is enough”.
Keep the original source entry in the log even when the final figure uses a different unit. This lets another reviewer retrace the arithmetic and check which quantity was copied. It does not make the log a scientific accuracy certificate.
Extension: remove a source rule
Now remove the card's instruction that every dimension label must contain a unit. Replace it with: “A shared-unit legend may be used if its scope is explicit.” Which decision changes?
Case 1 can now be repaired in another way: keep “Width: 18” only if a visible legend explicitly says that all dimension labels in this rectangle use millimetres. A vague “units as shown” note does not define that scope. The change does not repair the 18 cm conversion error, the unsupported instrument claim, or the height-to-width row swap.
Discuss whether a reader can recover the intended quantity, value, and unit from the final visual alone. Record any reader confusion as feedback on this proposed activity, not as evidence that it improves learning or that a real class has used it.
Scope, credit, and reuse
This is a label-review exercise, not an independent review of Figran and not guidance for validating research measurements. AI-assisted images and polished layouts still require source, domain, and venue checks for real scientific use. Figran's website is figran.net; public contact is support@figran.net.
The original teaching text and invented card are offered under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International. Credit Figran Team and this article title, link the licence, and indicate changes. This licence does not cover Figran software, brand assets, Mataroa software, or the platform interface.