Prepared by Figran Team with AI-assisted writing. This is an original figure-review exercise using invented card inventories. It contains no participant, experiment or measurement data, and reports no learning outcome or scientific validation.
The fictional source
Imagine four labelled boxes of cards. The source gives two counts for each box: cards marked “selected” and all cards in that box. “Selected” is only a label in this exercise. It does not mean correct, approved, successful or better. The counts below were chosen to illustrate arithmetic; they are not observations from a real activity.
| Box | Selected cards | Total cards |
|---|---|---|
| A | 12 | 40 |
| B | 18 | 90 |
| C | 8 | Not recorded |
| D | 0 | 0 |
A draft caption says, “Box B has the larger selected share because 18 is larger than 12.” A reviewer must check whether the source supports that sentence before making a polished chart.
Check the question before the display
If the question is “Which box has more selected cards?”, compare the selected counts. Box B has 18, and Box A has 12. The supported statement is that B has more selected cards than A. The same comparison says nothing about the proportion of cards selected in either box.
If the question is “What fraction of each box's cards is selected?”, the denominator is the total card count for that same box. For A, 12 divided by 40 is 0.30, or 30%. For B, 18 divided by 90 is 0.20, or 20%. A therefore has the larger selected share, even though B has the larger selected count.
Keep the unit consistent: selected cards divided by all cards in the same box. These calculations concern a share of an inventory, not a rate per minute, an improvement over time or a probability that a scientific claim is true.
Two entries need different treatments
C has a recorded selected count but no recorded total. Its selected share cannot be calculated from this source. Do not replace “not recorded” with zero, guess a total, or borrow A's or B's denominator.
D has a total of zero. Its proposed calculation would be 0 divided by 0, which is undefined. Do not write 0% merely because its selected count is zero. “No cards in the box” is a supported inventory statement; a percentage selected is not defined for this empty box.
Try a repair
- Rewrite the caption as two separate sentences: one about the selected count, one about the selected share.
- Add a denominator beside each displayed count used in a share calculation.
- Mark C as “total not recorded; share not calculable from the source”.
- Mark D as “empty box; selected share undefined”.
- Check whether a legend uses “selected” as a quality judgement. If it does, remove that added meaning or obtain an appropriate source for it.
Answer guide
A suitable pair of sentences is: “B has more selected cards than A: 18 versus 12. A has the larger selected share: 30% versus 20%.” Neither sentence supplies a result for C. D's zero total must remain visible, alongside the explanation that its share is undefined.
Review record
Record the question, numerator, denominator, source label and supported reader statement. Add a separate line for missing or zero denominators. Choose a table or chart only after those statements are settled; a layout choice cannot supply missing data or make a division defined.
Scope and disclosure
Figran Team is affiliated with Figran, a commercial AI-assisted scientific visual creation service: https://figran.net/. Any generated visual needs human checking against its source and the applicable institution or publication policy. This proposed teaching activity is not an evaluated classroom intervention, an accessibility certification or evidence of improved learning.
The original teaching text and invented card inventory may be reused under CC BY 4.0: CC BY 4.0. Software and brand assets are excluded. Public contact: support@figran.net .