figran

A cumulative line needs a starting count and interval rules

By Figran Team. We are associated with Figran, a commercial AI-assisted visual creation service. This original paper-and-table activity was prepared with AI assistance and checked by its author for internal arithmetic consistency. All times, card counts and arrival assignments below are invented. They are not tracking records, experimental data, a classroom result, or evidence about a product's performance. No software account or purchase is needed.

A cumulative count answers how many cards have been counted by a boundary. It does not directly state how many arrived during the next interval. This activity keeps boundary totals, interval additions and interval-average rates in separate fields, then asks what the totals cannot reveal about the timing of individual arrivals.

1. Declare a counting contract

Use elapsed time t in minutes, with observation boundaries at t = 0, 1, 3, 4 and 7. The intervals between observations are therefore unequal. C(t) means the cumulative number of cards counted by time t, including any arrival exactly at that boundary. There are 5 cards already counted at t = 0.

For this fictional version, each later card is counted exactly once, cards are never removed from the count, there is no reset, and the counting definition stays unchanged. The boundary values are exact integers rather than rounded estimates. These conditions are part of the supplied model; they must be checked rather than assumed for a real counter.

Assign arrivals to intervals (a, b]: later than a and at or before b. An arrival exactly at a is already included in C(a), so it must not be counted again in C(b) - C(a). The opening 5 cards belong to the supplied starting inventory; their individual earlier arrival times are not provided.

This is a cumulative count of arrivals under a fixed rule, not a claim that every quantity called a total must rise. An inventory with removals, a signed account balance, a reset counter or a revised definition would need its own contract. Do not use this exercise to infer their behaviour.

2. Retain every supplied boundary value

Source Card A supplies the following complete boundary table. It does not supply individual arrival times between the boundaries.

Boundary t (minutes) Cumulative cards C(t)
0 5
1 8
3 12
4 12
7 21

For an interval (a, b], subtract the earlier cumulative count from the later one: additions = C(b) - C(a). Divide that difference by the duration b - a to obtain an interval-average arrival rate. The units are cards per minute. This quotient is not an instantaneous rate at either endpoint.

Interval (minutes) Duration (minutes) Earlier C(a) Later C(b) Added cards Average cards per minute
(0, 1] 1 5 8 3 3
(1, 3] 2 8 12 4 2
(3, 4] 1 12 12 0 0
(4, 7] 3 12 21 9 3

The additions sum to 3 + 4 + 0 + 9 = 16 cards. The same result follows from the two outer boundaries: C(7) - C(0) = 21 - 5 = 16. Intermediate cumulative counts cancel when the successive differences are added.

The final total of 21 includes the 5 opening cards. It is therefore not the number added after t = 0. Adding the cumulative values instead gives 5 + 8 + 12 + 12 + 21 = 58. That sum repeatedly includes cards counted at more than one boundary; it is not the number of distinct cards or additions in this activity.

3. Keep duration beside every rate

The largest addition is 9 cards in (4, 7], while the highest interval-average rate is shared by (0, 1] and (4, 7], both 3 cards per minute. More arrivals over a longer interval do not by themselves imply a larger average rate.

Across the whole seven-minute observation window, the average is 16/7 cards per minute. Do not take the unweighted mean of the four interval rates: (3 + 2 + 0 + 3)/4 = 2. Those intervals do not have equal durations. Weighting each rate by its duration recovers the overall result: (3 x 1 + 2 x 2 + 0 x 1 + 3 x 3)/(1 + 2 + 1 + 3) = 16/7.

The repeated values C(3) = C(4) = 12 imply zero additions in (3, 4] under this exact, no-removal contract. With removals, resets, rounding, missing observations or a changed definition, equal displayed totals would not automatically support the same conclusion. Preserve the assumptions beside the calculation.

4. Do not invent the curve between observations

A straight segment between (1, 8) and (3, 12) would pass through (2, 10). That is a linear interpolation rule chosen for a display. The two supplied endpoint totals alone do not establish C(2) = 10 or a constant instantaneous arrival rate.

Consider two extra fictional timing assignments that both preserve those endpoints. In assignment E, all four interval arrivals occur at t = 1.5, so C(2) = 12. In assignment L, all four occur at t = 2.5, so C(2) = 8. Both have C(1) = 8, C(3) = 12 and the same interval-average rate of 2 cards per minute. The activity allows several cards to arrive at one instant.

These assignments are counterexamples to unique reconstruction, not assertions about the hidden arrivals in Source Card A. Neither assignment is implied by the endpoint table. A connected line can help a reader follow the observation order, but it must not silently become new source data about times that were never supplied.

If an illustration uses a straight connector, label it as a display choice and retain the boundary table. Exact integer-valued arrival counts need not follow every fractional value on a smooth or sloping connector. No rendered chart or measured image is supplied here.

5. Try seven review tasks

Task 1. Rebuild the interval table from the five boundary counts. Calculate all durations, additions and interval-average rates. Give the number added in (0, 7] and the average over that whole window.

Task 2. A caption says, "58 cards arrived, because the five points sum to 58." Repair it. Explain what the final value 21 and the difference 16 each describe, including the role of the 5 opening cards.

Task 3. Under the declared (a, b] rule, which interval receives an arrival exactly at t = 1, t = 3 and t = 7? Would a card at t = 0 be counted again in (0, 1]? Does this table cover an arrival at t = 8?

Task 4. Someone reads C(2) = 10 from a straight connector. Give the endpoint arithmetic behind that interpolation and the two supplied alternative timing assignments. Which fields remain identical, and which missing information would be needed to know the actual C(2)?

Task 5. A separate Source Card B starts with 105 opening cards and retains exactly the same four interval additions as A. Write its five cumulative values. Which additions and rates stay unchanged? Is its final cumulative count still 21? Treat B as a different fictional starting inventory, not a relabelling of A's actual count units.

Task 6. A new packet supplies only C(1) = 8, C(3) = 12, C(4) = 12 and C(7) = 21. It declares the same exact, nonnegative, no-removal count rule but omits C(0). Find the known additions in (1, 7]. Give two different valid starting counts and their resulting additions in (0, 7]. Can the full-window addition be uniquely recovered?

Task 7. First inspect a candidate series 5, 8, 12, 11, 21 at the same five times. Identify why it violates A's stated contract without inventing an explanation. Separately, an explicitly corrected source version A2 keeps A's first four boundary values but changes C(7) from 21 to 20. Recompute its last-interval addition, last-interval average and full-window addition and average. Write a caption that identifies A2 and its actual boundaries.

6. Worked answers

Answer 1. Durations are 1, 2, 1 and 3 minutes. Differences are 8 - 5 = 3, 12 - 8 = 4, 12 - 12 = 0 and 21 - 12 = 9 cards. The interval-average rates are 3, 2, 0 and 3 cards per minute. The added count in (0, 7] is 16, and its average is 16/7 cards per minute. Adding four rates without their durations would discard part of the source.

Answer 2. The arithmetic sum 58 is a sum of cumulative observations, with repeated inclusion of earlier cards. One repair is: "Source Card A has 21 cards counted by t = 7, including 5 already counted at t = 0; 16 cards were added in (0, 7]." Do not call 21 the additions after the opening boundary or claim that a total of 58 distinct cards was supplied.

Answer 3. An arrival at t = 1 belongs to (0, 1], one at t = 3 belongs to (1, 3], and one at t = 7 belongs to (4, 7]. A card at t = 0 is already covered by the opening inventory C(0), so it is excluded from (0, 1]. Time 8 is outside the table's declared observation window. Do not silently extend the final interval or assign a new arrival to the known total 21.

Answer 4. The straight segment increases by 4 cards over 2 minutes, so its interpolated halfway value is 8 + (4/2) x 1 = 10 at t = 2. Assignment E instead gives 12 at t = 2, and assignment L gives 8. Both preserve the supplied endpoint counts, interval addition 4 and interval-average rate 2. Individual arrival times, or an independently supplied value at t = 2, would resolve that missing information; a chosen connector cannot do so.

Answer 5. B's cumulative values are 105, 108, 112, 112 and 121. Its differences are still 3, 4, 0 and 9, so the four interval rates and full-window average 16/7 remain unchanged. Its full-window addition is 16, while its final total is 121. Adding 100 already-counted cards to the starting inventory changes every cumulative level. It does not add 100 new arrivals to each later interval or make B the same source inventory as A.

Answer 6. The additions in (1, 7] are known: 21 - 8 = 13. A starting count C(0) = 0 is consistent with 8 additions in (0, 1] and 21 in (0, 7]. C(0) = 5 is also consistent, giving 3 in the first interval and 16 in the whole window. C(0) = 8 would give 0 and 13 respectively. More generally, the declared rule allows integer C(0) from 0 through 8; full-window additions range from 13 through 21. Nothing in this new packet identifies a unique opening count. Do not borrow A's missing value 5 without source authority.

Answer 7. The candidate falls from 12 at t = 3 to 11 at t = 4, giving a difference of -1. That contradicts an exact cumulative arrival count with no removals, reset or changed definition. It does not prove whether there was a transcription error, reset, removal, or a different process; clarification or a corrected source is needed.

For the separate explicit correction A2, the last addition is 20 - 12 = 8 cards over 3 minutes, with average 8/3 cards per minute. The full-window addition is 20 - 5 = 15 and the full-window average is 15/7 cards per minute. The earlier three interval additions remain 3, 4 and 0. Retain version A2 so a later reader does not accidentally combine its final total with A's former difference 9.

One suitable caption is: "Source Card A2, a fictional exact cumulative arrival count with no removals or resets. At elapsed minutes 0, 1, 3, 4 and 7, cumulative counts are 5, 8, 12, 12 and 20 cards. There are 15 additions in (0, 7], averaging 15/7 cards per minute; the last interval (4, 7] adds 8, averaging 8/3. Intermediate arrival times are not supplied, and any straight connectors are display choices. These values are an invented teaching example, not observations or a product result."

7. Keep a review record and the reuse limits

Retain the source version, what is counted, whether removals or resets are possible, the opening boundary value, all observation times, endpoint-inclusion rule, units and exactness or rounding status. Keep interval differences and durations beside any derived averages. If a figure changes version, recalculate every field affected by that change instead of updating only the final label.

This activity establishes arithmetic consequences of its own declared fictional contract. It does not validate an unknown dataset, establish an instantaneous rate, estimate an unseen arrival schedule or demonstrate a learning benefit. A real cumulative display must be checked against its actual definitions and source records.

Creator's commercial website: Figran. Public contact: support@figran.net. We are affiliated with the service; this is not an independent review. The complete activity can be used without visiting the website or creating a software account.

The original educational text and invented source tables are offered under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International. Attribute Figran Team, identify this activity, link the licence and indicate changes. This licence covers our teaching text and fictional values only; it does not cover Figran software, brand assets, third-party materials or the hosting platform.