figran

A missing-relationship worksheet for an invented teaching figure

By Figran Team. We work on Figran, so this is a brand-authored teaching resource. AI assisted the drafting; the wording and examples were reviewed for this exercise. It does not report an experiment, a scientific finding, or a tested learning benefit. You can complete it on paper without using Figran.

Why an omitted line needs a label

A diagram shows selected relationships. A blank space between two boxes can mean that a relationship is outside the scope, unknown, intentionally omitted, or simply not drawn yet. These meanings are different. This worksheet asks a reviewer to state which meaning the author intended before adding an arrow.

The entire example below is invented. The boxes are classroom tasks, not biological entities or measurements. An arrow means only “next task in this invented sequence.” It does not mean cause, evidence, strength, probability, time taken, or measured influence.

The tiny source brief

The author supplies exactly these statements:

  1. A learner writes a question on a card.
  2. The learner sorts that card into a topic group.
  3. A peer reviews the wording after sorting.
  4. The brief does not describe what happens after peer review.
  5. The brief does not specify whether any task can be repeated.

A draft figure has three boxes: Question card, Topic group, and Peer review. Two arrows run from Question card to Topic group and from Topic group to Peer review. Nothing is drawn after Peer review. No return arrow is drawn.

Four statuses for an absent relationship

Use one status per proposed line. Each status is an instruction for this exercise, not a universal notation standard.

  • Supported: the source brief explicitly states the relationship. A line may be drawn, with its meaning in the key.
  • Unknown: the source brief supplies no answer. Record the question rather than inventing a line.
  • Outside scope: the figure deliberately stops before this relationship. State the boundary in a caption.
  • Draft omission: the author has a source statement but has not drawn its relationship. Record that statement before repairing the draft.

“Not drawn” by itself is not one of these statuses. Also avoid replacing Unknown with “no relationship”: absence of information is not information about absence.

Complete a five-field review record

For each proposed line, write:

  • The two endpoints, using the exact box labels.
  • The proposed meaning of the line.
  • The source statement that supports that meaning, or “none supplied.”
  • The status and a short reason.
  • The next action: draw, ask, caption the boundary, or repair an omission.

Keep the source statement separate from the action. Wanting a cleaner layout does not supply evidence for a new relationship.

Worked decisions

Proposal A: Question card to Peer review, skipping Topic group. Its proposed meaning is “next task.” No statement supports skipping the sorting task. Mark Unknown and ask whether the author intends a shortcut; do not add this arrow to the source-based draft.

Proposal B: Peer review to Question card, meaning “repeat from the beginning.” Statement 5 leaves repetition unspecified. Mark Unknown and record the question. A curved return arrow would still assert a relationship, even if it looks decorative.

Proposal C: An unnamed task after Peer review. Statement 4 says that the brief stops here. Mark Outside scope and add a caption: “This figure covers question writing, sorting, and peer review only; later tasks are not described.” Do not invent a fourth box.

Proposal D: Topic group to Peer review in a second draft where that arrow is missing. Statement 3 supplies this next-task relationship. Mark Draft omission, copy statement 3 into the record, and restore the arrow with the same key. This is a repair of an explicit omission, not a new scientific claim.

Peer exercise

Exchange the four records with a partner. The partner should be able to identify which proposal needs a question, which needs a caption, and which repairs an explicit statement. If a status changes, write the new source statement that caused the change. A vote, a visual preference, or an AI suggestion alone is not a new source statement.

Before sharing a final figure, check that its caption defines the arrow, names the scope boundary, and leaves unknown relationships visible as questions in the accompanying notes. Keep this invented example clearly separate from any real research material.

Reuse and attribution

Original teaching text: CC BY 4.0, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Attribute Figran Team and this worksheet title, link the license, and indicate changes. The license covers this teaching text only; it does not license Figran software, its logo, or third-party material.

Figran: https://figran.net/ Public contact: support@figran.net