A multi-panel figure can use position to guide a reader without describing a timeline. This worksheet asks a reviewer to separate those two jobs before approving a new layout. It is intended for a teacher or learner reviewing a teaching visual, including a draft prepared with AI assistance.
The source briefs and panel descriptions below are invented. No figure was generated or tested with a class, and no learning benefit, experimental result or tool performance is claimed.
Start with two kinds of order
For this exercise, use these working definitions:
- Reading order: the route the author asks a reader to follow through the page.
- Source-required order: a sequence that the supplied source brief explicitly requires.
A reading route may help someone find labels. It does not by itself establish that one depicted event occurred before another, caused it, or performed better. Those claims need their own source support. Panel letters also need an explained role: here, letters identify panels unless the caption explicitly assigns another meaning.
Keep a small panel inventory
Before changing position, record the following for each panel. A letter is a reference label, while the panel's content name identifies what must stay attached to it.
| Content name | Current reference label | Required source relation | Caption reference | Proposed new position |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [short description] | [A, B or another label] | [exact source wording, or none specified] | [sentence that points here] | [position requested] |
Record the intended reading route separately. If the source does not specify a sequence, write none specified in the source-relation column. That is a statement about the brief used in this exercise, not proof that no relation exists in the wider subject.
Four invented review cases
For each case, choose approve, revise, or hold for clarification, then name the text or reference that governs your decision. More than one revision can be reasonable if the decision preserves the supplied information.
Case 1: a comparison becomes a timeline
Source brief: "Compare the wording on a round card and a square card. Either card may be read first."
Draft description: panel A contains the round card; panel B contains the square card. A new caption calls A "before" and B "after."
Question: Does the brief support those temporal words? Record one change that would preserve the comparison without adding a timeline.
Case 2: a required task sequence is reversed
Source brief: "Write one label, then review the label you wrote."
Draft description: panel A shows writing; panel B shows review. A layout request places the review panel first, keeps A attached to writing and B attached to review, and leaves the caption "A, then B" unchanged.
Question: After the move, which job is being referred to by each letter? Record how you would preserve the required task sequence and make the caption references accurate. Do not add a claim about task duration or effectiveness.
Case 3: position changes but an old reference survives
Source brief: "Place the two alternative captions side by side. There is no preferred caption."
Draft description: panel A contains caption Cedar and panel B contains caption Birch. The layout request swaps their positions and assigns A to the panel now on the left. A nearby instruction still says "Copy Cedar from panel A."
Question: Trace the content name, the new letter and the instruction together. Name the reference that needs revision before approval.
Case 4: a permitted omission needs a visible boundary
Source brief: "Show a writing task, a review task and an optional second review. The second review may be omitted from a shorter handout."
Draft description: the shorter handout contains only writing and review. Its caption still says "The three tasks shown below."
Question: Is the omission permitted? Is the caption accurate? Record both answers rather than treating permission to omit as permission to leave an inaccurate count.
Suggested answer key
- Revise. The brief allows either reading order and supplies no before/after relation. Use a comparison caption such as "Two cards for comparing wording" and remove the temporal claim. The page may still state a reading route.
- Approve after checking references. A still identifies writing and B still identifies review, so "A, then B" preserves the required task sequence even if B is placed first on the page. State that intended reading route in the accompanying text and verify the final labels. If the actual labels or caption no longer match those tasks, revise or hold instead. Page position alone does not require a different task sequence or justify a claim about timing or effectiveness.
- Revise. Under the requested relabeling, Cedar is now B. Update the instruction to its actual new reference, or keep stable panel identifiers and explain their placement. Verify the final rendered labels rather than assuming that a move updated every cross-reference.
- Revise. Omitting the second review is permitted by this brief. A caption that counts three displayed tasks is inaccurate when only two remain. Update the count and identify the omitted optional task in an accompanying note if that context is needed.
A short approval record
Complete these five lines after checking the final visual and its text companion:
- Source brief/version used: [identify it]
- Required order: [quote the supplied relation, or state none specified]
- Actual panel-content-to-label mapping: [list it]
- Reading route and caption references checked: [state the route and any repairs]
- Decision and unresolved question: [approve, revise or hold, with a reason]
This is a planning and review exercise. For a real scientific figure, a subject reviewer must also check whether the source is suitable and whether the depicted content is accurate. This worksheet does not perform that validation.
Prepared by Figran Team, which is associated with Figran. AI assisted the wording. This is an original educational exercise, not an independent product review. Public contact: support@figran.net.
The original worksheet text is available under CC BY 4.0. Software, brand assets and any separately linked material retain their own licenses.