By Figran Team
Two reviewers can recommend different changes without either having checked the same question. This worksheet asks learners to name the disputed object, trace each recommendation to an invented source brief, and state what still needs a decision. It is an exercise in documenting a review, not a test of which reviewer sounds more confident.
All records, figures and reviewer comments below are fictional. No classroom trial, scientific finding or improvement in learning is claimed. Use paper, a text editor or a whiteboard; a Figran account is not needed.
The shared source brief
Use this brief as the sole source for the exercise:
“Records move from Receipt to Check. A checked record marked complete may move from Check to File. An unchecked record moves from Check to Hold. Solid arrows represent permitted transitions. Dotted lines are annotations only. This brief provides no timing information and assigns no owner to a stage.”
The words “record,” “complete” and “unchecked” are exercise labels. They do not describe patients, biological samples or an actual research process. Treat the brief as a small writing fixture, not a general rule about real systems.
Before choosing a correction
Keep three questions separate:
- Does a proposed statement agree with the source?
- Does the change meet the particular figure's approved purpose?
- What did the reviewer actually check?
Agreement with one question does not automatically answer the others. A change can show a source-supported route while dropping a route the assignment required. A correct label can also appear beside an unchecked arrow.
Use one disagreement record per disputed object. Write the object, each recommendation, the exact source sentence, any approved task instruction, the decision and its remaining limit. Record a missing task instruction as missing; do not let a vote stand in for it.
Case 1: two valid edits, one required lane
Draft object: a solid arrow from Check to File, labelled “unchecked.”
Approved task instruction: “The figure must retain a File lane for completed records.”
Reviewer A: “Replace unchecked with complete.”
Reviewer B: “Keep unchecked and change the destination to Hold.”
Both proposed routes appear in the brief, but they would communicate different parts of it. Which edit fits this task, and what would you do if the approved task instruction were unavailable?
Suggested resolution: choose A for the stated task. The source supports Check-to-File for a record marked complete, and the task specifically retains the File lane. B would produce a supported unchecked-to-Hold route, but would replace the required File lane. Record B as a relevant alternative for another figure purpose, rather than calling it scientifically false.
Without the approved task instruction, the source alone cannot tell you which lane the author intended to retain. Ask the owner to select the intended route before changing the figure. Do not infer intent from which reviewer responded last.
Case 2: removing a claim is not proving its opposite
Draft object: a stage labelled “Fast Check.”
Reviewer A: “Change the label to Check; the brief does not establish speed.”
Reviewer B: “The stage is slow, so call it Slow Check.”
Decide what wording the source supports and what remains untested.
Suggested resolution: use “Check.” A removes a timing claim the brief does not supply. B introduces a different timing claim that the brief also does not supply. Neither fast nor slow is established by this exercise's source.
Write the limit explicitly: “Timing not assessed; source supplies only the stage name.” Do not write “Slow disproved” or “Fast verified.” If timing matters to the intended lesson, it needs a different approved source and a separate review.
Case 3: an annotation and its caption need separate decisions
Draft object: a dotted line from Receipt to File, with no arrowhead. Its caption says, “Shortcut for checked records.”
Reviewer A: “The line shows a permitted shortcut; keep it.”
Reviewer B: “A dotted annotation cannot make a process claim; the caption needs correction.”
Assess the line's visual role and the caption's statement separately.
Suggested resolution: B identifies a real mismatch. The legend makes a dotted line an annotation, and the source gives no direct Receipt-to-File transition. The caption nevertheless asserts a shortcut. Changing only the line's style would not establish that shortcut.
For a non-process note, replace the caption with wording that does not assert a route, such as “Annotation connecting the two labelled stages,” provided that this is the intended note. For an actual route diagram, show the supported Receipt-to-Check and complete Check-to-File arrows instead. Record the owner's chosen purpose; do not quietly turn a note into a transition.
The exercise does not establish what any real system can or cannot do. It establishes only what this particular brief authorizes the teaching figure to say.
Case 4: a review scope cannot be enlarged by agreement
Draft object: a figure with stage labels, arrow labels and a caption.
Reviewer A: “The stage names match the brief. I checked those names only.”
Reviewer B: “The layout is readable. I checked spacing only.”
Proposed publication note: “Both reviewers agree that all relationships and the caption are source-verified.”
Is the proposed note supported by the reported checks?
Suggested resolution: no. Neither report documents an arrow-relationship or caption check. A's stage-name check and B's spacing check can both be recorded, but combining them does not create evidence of a review neither person performed.
Use a narrower note: “Stage names checked against the brief; spacing reviewed. Arrow relationships and caption wording remain unchecked.” Assign those remaining checks before describing them as verified. Do not rename “unchecked” as “failed,” since this case contains no completed failing check of those objects.
A disagreement record to copy
Object and figure version: Reviewer A's recommendation and stated scope: Reviewer B's recommendation and stated scope: Source sentence relevant to this object: Approved task instruction, or “not supplied”: Decision and the reason tied to that evidence: Remaining question, person responsible for deciding it, and next check:
Keep the two original recommendations visible beside the resolution. If a new source or task instruction changes the decision, add a dated revision note explaining the change. Do not rewrite the earlier report to make it appear that the reviewer checked the new material.
For discussion, ask whether the decision followed from source wording, from the figure's approved purpose, or from a newly completed check. If none applies, retain an unresolved question instead of manufacturing a consensus.
Authorship, use and limits
Figran Team is associated with Figran. AI assisted the drafting of this original teaching exercise; the examples and suggested resolutions were reviewed for the stated source and task. This is brand-authored educational material, not an independent product review or a claim that a tool validates science.
The teaching text is available under CC BY 4.0. That licence covers this text, not Figran software, logos or other brand assets. Public contact: support@figran.net.