figran

Which objects are inside the outline? A boundary-membership review lab

Start here: an outline is a claim about membership

Question: What must a reviewer know before counting objects inside a teaching diagram?

This is an original text-only teaching lab by Figran Team, prepared with AI assistance. Figran is a commercial scientific drawing service. The lab does not require a Figran account and can be used with a pencil or any drawing tool. All objects, labels, counts and layouts below are invented; they describe no experiment, patient, specimen or measured result.

An outline can look like a container, a highlight, a region of interest or a decorative frame. Its appearance alone does not settle which of these roles the author intended. Before counting, write down three things: the named region or group, the unit being counted, and the rule that assigns an object to that region. Also record what happens to objects on the border.

For each case, answer from the stated facts. Separate a count that follows from an explicit rule from a count that needs an author decision. A reasonable result can be a number, a request for clarification, or two conditional results. No learning-effect claim is made for this exercise.

Review check: Check the region name, counting unit, inclusion rule and border rule before deriving a total.

Case A: nearby is not inside

Question: How many objects belong to Frame Cedar under the stated rule?

Invented source record: Frame Cedar is a closed rectangle. An object belongs to Cedar when its centre lies strictly inside the rectangle. Three distinct circles have names: Ibis has its centre inside Cedar, Jade has its centre inside Cedar, and Lime has its centre outside Cedar. None touches the border. Lime sits visually closer to Jade than Ibis does. A dashed arrow joins Jade to Lime.

Question: choose the count supported by this record: two, three, or not determined. Then say whether the dashed arrow changes the membership count.

Answer: two. Ibis and Jade satisfy the stated centre-inside rule. Lime does not. The record does not give the arrow any membership meaning, so the connection and visual proximity do not add Lime to Cedar.

Repair note: if a drawing suggests that all arrow-connected objects are members, add a separate labelled group or explicitly define an arrow-connected membership rule. Do not silently change the centre-inside rule. The count in this case is a result of the invented rule, not a biological finding.

Review check: Two is supported. An arrow or short visual distance does not override the explicit centre-inside rule.

Case B: a border case needs a border rule

Question: Can we report one exact membership total for Frame Birch?

Invented source record: Frame Birch is closed. Oak and Pine lie completely inside it. Reed crosses its border: part of Reed is inside and part is outside. The source says, “count objects in Birch,” but does not say whether to use the centre, the whole outline, any overlap, or another rule. It gives no centre coordinate for Reed.

Question: a draft caption states “Birch contains three objects.” Is that statement established by the source? List two possible rules and the totals they would produce.

Answer: one exact total is not established. Under a wholly-inside rule, Oak and Pine count and Reed does not, giving two. Under an any-overlap rule, all three count. A centre-inside rule cannot be applied to Reed from the information supplied.

Repair note: ask the author which rule is intended, record it in the caption or legend, and apply it consistently. Do not choose the rule simply because it produces a preferred total. Until clarified, retain the uncertainty in the review record rather than presenting either conditional answer as the original source claim.

Review check: Two and three are conditional results for different rules. The original record does not choose between them.

Case C: nesting does not create a second object

Question: How many distinct objects are in Outer Alder?

Invented source record: Outer Alder is a closed frame containing Inner Hazel. The counting unit is a distinct named object, counted once. Seed A and Seed B are inside Inner Hazel and therefore also inside Outer Alder. Seed C is inside Outer Alder but outside Inner Hazel. No objects lie on either border. The letters A, B and C identify three objects, not three kinds with an unspecified number of members.

Question: a review table contains “Inner Hazel: 2” and “Outer Alder: 3.” May we add these entries to say that the two frames contain five distinct objects in total?

Answer: no. Outer Alder contains three distinct objects. The Inner Hazel entry counts two of those same objects again. Adding the two regional totals does not produce a count of distinct objects across the union of the regions.

Repair note: specify whether a table reports regional memberships or unique objects. If regional totals overlap, show that overlap or state that the totals must not be added to derive a unique-object total. The issue is the identity and counting rule, not the size or colour of the two frames.

Review check: Outer Alder contains three distinct objects. Adding overlapping regional totals counts A and B twice.

Case D: a highlight is not automatically a region

Question: Does the dotted mark define a membership set?

Invented source record: a dotted arc surrounds labels Moss and Fern on two sides, leaving a large opening on the third side. The source calls the arc a “highlight for discussion.” It does not call it a boundary, region or group. Brook appears near the opening. The source gives no membership rule for the highlight and no instruction to count it.

Question: a draft changes the caption to “The dotted region contains two items.” What new claim has the draft introduced?

Answer: it has promoted a discussion highlight into a membership region and supplied an implied inclusion rule. Neither decision is stated in the source. The presence of two nearby labels is insufficient to establish a two-member set defined by that mark.

Repair note: keep the source wording “highlight for discussion,” or obtain an explicit region definition. If the author intends a region, define its boundary and inclusion rule rather than closing the gap only to make the image look tidy. Visual cleanup should not silently supply missing scientific or instructional meaning.

Review check: The draft introduced a region and membership rule. Retain the highlight wording or obtain an explicit definition.

Case E: labels and colours can describe different sets

Question: Which objects belong to Group Amber?

Invented source record: Group Amber is defined in the source as the objects named A and C. A separate legend says that a blue fill marks “needs a spelling check.” In the draft, A and B are blue, while C is unfilled. The legend does not say that blue fill denotes Group Amber. There are exactly three named objects, A, B and C.

Question: a viewer lists A and B as Group Amber because both are blue. What is the source-supported membership list, and what does the blue fill list instead?

Answer: Group Amber contains A and C. The blue fill marks A and B for a spelling check. Both lists can be true because they describe different properties. The source does not say that every member of a group must have the same review status.

Repair note: distinguish the group label from the review-status key. If a visual aid needs a consistent group colour, choose one only after deciding how to retain the separate spelling-check information. Do not erase C from the group to force the two lists to agree. This exercise makes no claim about colour accessibility or any biological classification.

Review check: Group Amber is A and C. Blue fill marks A and B for a separate spelling check.

A short review record before sharing

Question: What should a reviewer write down when membership remains unclear?

Use a record with six fields: source statement; region or group name; counting unit; inclusion rule; border or overlap rule; and decision status. Decision status can be confirmed, conditional, or awaiting clarification. Add the case label so that another reviewer can find the same facts.

Try this repair sentence for Case B: “Oak and Pine are confirmed inside Birch. Reed intersects the border; its membership is awaiting the author's inclusion rule.” This preserves the stated facts without pretending that the source supplied a single total.

Try this sentence for Case C: “The regional counts overlap. Outer Alder contains three distinct objects; Inner Hazel contains two of those same objects.” The sentence tells the reader why adding regional totals would be misleading.

Before sharing a diagram, check that its caption, labels and membership marks express the same rule. A reviewer should be able to trace the decision to a stated source fact. This record is a review aid, not a guarantee of scientific correctness, accessibility compliance, classroom effectiveness or error prevention.

Review check: Record the rule and uncertainty. Preserve overlapping identities instead of silently forcing a preferred total.

Reuse, attribution and limits

Question: Who made this lab, and what may be reused?

Created by Figran Team as a brand-affiliated original teaching resource, with AI-assisted drafting. Public contact: support@figran.net. Figran website: figran.net. The commercial relationship is disclosed; this is not an independent product review or an account of classroom testing.

The teaching text, invented case records, questions and feedback in this lab are offered under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International. Credit “Figran Team — boundary-membership review lab,” retain the brand and AI disclosure, link to the licence, and indicate changes when adapting the teaching text. This permission does not license Figran software, the Figran logo, Mataroa software, platform design, third-party media or trademarks.

No image, class roster, student identity or real experimental data is included. Do not turn a conditional answer into an established source fact. When adapting the cases, clearly label any invented records and write the intended inclusion rule. Human review remains necessary. The resource makes no measured learning or scientific-effect claim.

Review check: CC BY 4.0 covers this original teaching text and invented cases, not software, logos or platform materials.